We have the aviator outfit and are hoping to get the Afterschool one if it comes on sale in March. The reason that I ordered the aviator one first was because I was afraid that it would retire. It has been on the Monthly Specials page twice now. As far as the actual cuteness of the outfits, I prefer the Afterschool one. It looks so comfortable and casual. It reminds me of clothes worn by the kids on the Waltons tv show. Like someone else said, the aviator outfit does not have a shirt, which bothers me too.